Analog Ice Cream and Coffee

4.6 ( 229 reviews )
Checking... 6:30 AM - 9:00 PM See Hours
$1–10
10649 N Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, WI 54234, United States
+1 920-854-1155

Located in scenic Sister Bay, WI, Analog Ice Cream and Coffee stands out as a vibrant hub for both coffee lovers and ice cream enthusiasts. This charming shop offers an eclectic atmosphere, enhanced by an array of vintage records and a disco ball that sets a fun tone, even during the early hours.

Patrons rave about the phenomenal ice cream variations sourced locally from Madison, WI, paired perfectly with their meticulously crafted coffees. A standout recommendation is the Flat White, which one espresso aficionado called "the best" after enjoying it iced, adorned with a sweet cold foam. Additionally, guests have praised the delightful breakfast options, including scrumptious pastries and breakfast burritos that elevate your morning experience.

The service is exceptional—staff members are consistently highlighted for their friendliness and willingness to engage customers. This commitment to hospitality, alongside quality drinks and delicious treats, creates an enjoyable space that invites you to linger. Whether you’re grabbing a morning pick-me-up or savoring a scoop of ice cream, Analog Ice Cream and Coffee promises a memorable experience. Highly recommended for anyone seeking a delightful blend of high-quality coffee and artisan ice cream!

Reviews For Analog Ice Cream and Coffee

reinaldo larotta
Jun 14,2025
Phenomenal Ice Cream variations. Great coffees, service and atmosphere!
Kelly Steffes
Jun 14,2025
This place was a lot of fun to visit. Small inside, but big personality! It had a bunch of records in the corner sitting area and a big disco ball going, even at 7:30AM. Ice cream was delicious and local from Madison, WI. Pastries, coffee, and breakfast burritos were awesome too! 100% recommend.
Heidi De La Teja
May 25,2025
Nectar of the gods!!! I am an espresso aficionado and appreciate a good cafe with bittersweet chocolate notes! Let me start off by saying the staff at this location are sensational! I think the girl that waited on me was Haley and I’m sorry I can’t remember the other two guys names but they were all super friendly outgoing and helpful. Thank you all for your awesome customer service! 10 Starz! I normally order a flat white when passing through but this time because of the heat and being over 90, I ordered the same flat white espresso drink, but on the rocks. They put a dash of sweet cold foam on the top and I must say it was the best flat white I’ve ever had. Wow simply, amazing! I went online and purchased a bag of their espresso beans from their Milwaukee store. I’m so glad all of this is available simply online. Thank you all for your stellar customer service. Cant wait to return!
Daniel Whiteside
Apr 25,2025
Had ice cream here last night, coffee this morning, everything was delicious! Super fun atmosphere and very friendly staff who happily took a group picture of us. Eating my cheddar and chive scone right now and had to post a review because it is FANTASTIC!
Jesse L
Apr 6,2025
While waiting for our table to be called at Al Johnson’s we decided to walk over to this cool little coffee shop for some drinks. The Cafe Aulait was great and my Iced Chai was also great. The prices are very reasonable and the 3 ladies working today were very pleasant and working hard/fast to take care of the continual line of people come to and fro...
Hannah M
Mar 30,2025
The ice cream and coffee here are delicious! They are open until 9pm on Saturdays which is super great for an after dinner treat. Their flavors are rich and creamy- highly recommend!
Rick Neuman
Mar 27,2025
Hey, dessert lovers! Every time we hit Door County, there's one spot we can't resist - Analog Ice Cream and Coffee in Sister Bay. It's like stepping into a sweet retro dream! But the real star here tonight? The Cherry Cobbler Crisp Ala Mode! If you haven't tasted Door County cherries, you haven't truly lived! Mixed into a crunchy cobbler and topped with creamy ice cream - it's a taste sensation that'll keep you coming back. So if you find yourself in Door County, don't miss out on Analog! Trust me, your tastebuds will thank you! #DoorCountyDesserts #cherrycobbler #AnalogIceCreamAndCoffee #CherryLove #doorCounty #desserttime #wisconsinfoodie
Alexander Leon
Mar 18,2025
This place has a great selection of flavors of ice cream. I definitely will be back!

Add a Review

Quality
Location
Price
Space
Service

Location

Appreciated by Others

Las Tapatias Mexican Restaurant
(317 review)
Las Tapatias Mexican Restaurant
  • 12798 Co Rd 512, Fellsmere, FL 32948, United States
Mexican restaurant
+1 772-918-3045
Seven Spices
(171 review)
Seven Spices
  • 906 E Gun Hill Rd, Bronx, NY 10469, United States
Caribbean restaurant
+1 347-326-8646
Emporium Kitchen & Wine Market
(623 review)
Emporium Kitchen & Wine Market
  • 254 E Perry St, Savannah, GA 31401, United States
Fine dining restaurant
+1 912-559-8400
Jones's Coffee House
(183 review)
Jones's Coffee House
  • Jones's Coffee House, 15 High St, Market Drayton TF9 1QB, United Kingdom
coffee shop
+44 1630 652042
Garden Wok
(431 review)
Garden Wok
  • 1090 2nd St S, Sartell, MN 56377, United States
chinese restaurant
+1 320-251-8888
Mongolian Grill
(952 review)
Mongolian Grill
  • 1135 S Camino Del Rio, Durango, CO 81303, United States
Chinese restaurant
+1 970-259-7228
El Vaquero West- Locust Grove
(419 review)
El Vaquero West- Locust Grove
  • 4266 Germanna Hwy # 102, Locust Grove, VA 22508, United States
Mexican restaurant
+1 540-972-2362
One Barrel American Bistro & Wine Bar
(456 review)
One Barrel American Bistro & Wine Bar
  • 3401 S Broadway # 110, Englewood, CO 80113, United States
American restaurant
+1 720-667-4781
T C Riley's Pub & Inn
(501 review)
T C Riley's Pub & Inn
  • 405 Carverton Rd, Wyoming, PA 18644, United States
pizza restaurant
+1 570-696-2500
Slye Fox Binbrook
(129 review)
Slye Fox Binbrook
  • 2537 Hamilton Regional Rd 56, Binbrook, ON L0R 1C0, Canada
restaurant
+1 905-692-0369